Benebone Wishbone vs Maplestick 2026 — Which Chew Toy Fits Your Dog

Benebone's chew toys have built a reputation for surviving dogs that destroy everything else. Two of their most popular shapes — the Wishbone and the Maplestick — get compared constantly, and the honest answer is they're not really competing with each other. They're built for different jobs.

The Real Difference Isn't Softness — It's Shape and Size

A common assumption is that one of these is a "softer puppy version" of the other. That's not accurate — both are made from the same durable nylon material. The real differences are shape (wishbone's curved ends vs maplestick's straight profile) and the size range each comes in, from tiny up to giant. For a puppy, the right move is picking a smaller size in whichever shape your dog prefers, not assuming one product is inherently gentler than the other.

Benebone Wishbone Chew Toy

Best for Aggressive Chewers

Benebone Wishbone Durable Dog Chew Toy, Real Bacon, Medium

★★★★☆ 104,840 reviews · 4.5 stars Top Rated

The wishbone shape gives dogs two curved ends to gnaw from, which tends to suit dogs that like to hold a toy between their paws while chewing. Made in the USA from durable nylon infused with real bacon flavour baked in rather than coated on, so the taste doesn't wear off quickly. With over 100,000 reviews it's one of the most trusted chew shapes in the Benebone range.

View on Amazon →

Benebone Maplestick Chew Toy

Best for Stick-Chewers

Benebone Maplestick Real Wood Durable Dog Chew Toy, Medium

★★★★☆ 19,034 reviews · 4.5 stars Top Rated

The Maplestick suits dogs that naturally gravitate toward sticks over bone or ball shapes. Made from the same durable nylon as the rest of the range, infused with real maple wood flavour rather than a coating. Available across Benebone's full size range from tiny to giant — for a puppy or smaller dog, sizing down is the key decision, not switching to a different product line.

View on Amazon →

Which one should you actually buy?

Dog likes to hold toys between their paws — Wishbone's curved ends give more to grip
Dog prefers a straight stick shape — Maplestick is the closer match to an actual stick
Puppy or small dog — pick the smallest appropriate size in whichever shape they respond to, not a separate "puppy" product
Not sure — the Wishbone has the larger review base and broader flavour appeal (bacon vs wood), so it's the safer default if you're choosing blind

Our Verdict

Both are durable — the shape is the real decision

Neither Benebone shape is objectively better than the other; they're built from the same tough nylon and hold up the same way under real chewing. Let your dog's chewing style pick the shape, and size down rather than assuming a separate softer product exists for puppies.

#ad · Everoxus participates in the Amazon Associates Program. If you purchase through our links we earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. This does not influence our recommendations.